2012 Celebrating 20 Years of Animal Law: Looking Back and Forward

Celebrating 20 Years of Animal Law: Looking Back and Forward marked a milestone gathering of animal law practitioners, scholars, students, and advocates in Portland, Oregon. Hosted at Lewis & Clark Law School, the conference reflected on two decades of progress in animal law while examining emerging challenges and opportunities shaping the future of the field.

Dates & Location

October 19–21, 2012
Lewis & Clark Law School
Portland, Oregon

In-Kind Sponsors

Compassion Flows

Uncle Paul’s Produce Market

Vega

Highlights & Reflections

The conference opened Friday evening with a welcome reception and keynote address at The Benson Hotel. Nancy Perry of the ASPCA delivered a keynote on persistence and progress in animal law, setting the tone for a weekend focused on both reflection and forward momentum.

Saturday’s sessions explored a wide range of substantive and practical issues, including ethics in animal law practice, challenges posed by ag-gag laws, innovative collaborations between advocates and industry, and global developments in animal protection, including progress toward legal reform in China. Panels also addressed the intersection of domestic violence and animal abuse, evolving legislative and litigation trends, and strategic debates within the movement about pragmatism and compromise. The day featured a lunchtime keynote by Congressman Earl Blumenauer on animal welfare in livable communities and concluded with an evening banquet, awards program, and a keynote address by Carol J. Adams, followed by a book signing commemorating the twentieth anniversary of The Sexual Politics of Meat.

Sunday’s programming focused on emerging voices, public health and nutrition, sustainable food systems, wildlife and marine mammal protection, and landmark litigation, including discussion of Tilikum v. SeaWorld. Additional panels examined the Animal Enterprise Terrorism Act, companion animal protections, agricultural subsidies, and career development for students and early-career advocates. The conference concluded with a student-focused career summit and closing reflections on the growth and future direction of animal law.

Celebrating 20 Years of Animal Law: Looking Back and Forward honored the field’s past achievements while reaffirming a shared commitment to advancing legal protections for animals through thoughtful dialogue, education, and collaboration.

Friday

6:00 – 8:00 p.m. PT

Welcome Reception & Keynote Address

The Benson Hotel (309 SW Broadway, Portland, OR 97205)

The conference will kick off with an evening reception. We invite you to enjoy appetizers and drinks while networking with fellow conference attendees.

 

7:30 – 8:00 p.m. PT

Keynote Address: Persistence and Progress in Animal Law

The Benson Hotel (309 SW Broadway, Portland, OR 97205)
Welcome & Introductions

Jaclyn Leeds, SALDF co-director; symposium editor, Animal Law Review; conference board member, Lewis & Clark Law School

Pamela Frasch, assistant dean, Animal Law Program; executive director, Center for Animal Law Studies at Lewis & Clark Law School

Joyce Tischler, founder and general counsel, Animal Legal Defense Fund

Nancy Perry, Senior Vice President of Government Relations, The American Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals (ASPCA)

 

Saturday

8:00 – 9:15 a.m. PT

Animal Law Ethics in the A.M.

Interactive Presentation
Wood Hall building Room 7

Kick off the conference with an exciting, interactive session exploring some of the most challenging ethical dilemmas animal law attorneys face in both practice and volunteer positions. Animal law expert Russ Mead and ethics professor Jeffrey Jones will lead attendees through a series of hypothetical scenarios which will examine difficult situations and how to handle them effectively while adhering to the Model Code of Professional Responsibility. Attendees will receive Oregon ethics CLE credits for this session.

Jeffrey Jones, Professor of Law, Lewis & Clark Law School
Russ Mead, The Shared Earth Foundation Visiting Professor, Center for Animal Law Studies, Lewis & Clark Law School

 

SALDF Breakfast

Wood Hall building Room 8

The SALDF breakfast allows students from around the county who are interested in animal law to meet, share ideas and information, and build stronger SALDF programs over coffee and vegan baked goods.

*Continental breakfast available in the lower level of Wood Hall at Lewis & Clark Law School

Kelly Levenda, Student Programs Attorney, Animal Legal Defense Fund
Jaclyn Leeds, SALDF co-director; symposium editor, Animal Law Review
Nicole Pallotta, Senior Policy Program Manager, Animal Legal Defense Fund

 

9:30 – 11:00 a.m. PT

Ag-gag Laws: Suppressing Speech and Activism

Plenary Panel
Wood Hall building Room 7

Ag-gag bills are popping up all over the country and the momentum behind them does not show signs of slowing down. Video footage of factory farms can be a valuable tool for animal advocates but often ag-gag laws criminalize such videos. This panel will give a status report of ag-gag laws and pending bills around the country and discuss legal challenges and grassroots solutions.

Lewis Bollard, Law Student, Yale Law School
Will Potter, Journalist and Author, GreenIsTheNewRed.com

 

Case Studies in Traditional and Unexpected Alliances: The Egg/Hen Bill, Antibiotics on the Farm, and Other Developments

Plenary Panel
Wood Hall building Room 8

This panel will discuss how working with instead of against animal industry and regulatory agencies may bring about improvements to animal welfare. Come learn about these exciting new strategies and what they mean for the future of animal law.

Paul Shapiro, Vice President, Farm Animal Protection, The Humane Society of the United States
Bruce Wagman, Partner, Schiff Hardin

 

11:15 a.m. – 12:45 p.m. PT

The Long March - TOwards Legal Protection for Animals in China

Wood Hall building Room 7

Paul Littlefair’s presentation will provide an update on developments in China since he spoke at the 2008 Conference, One Earth: Globalism & Animal Law. It will include a brief reference to animal law in other East Asian jurisdictions for comparison and then will move on to discuss the impact of high profile incidences of animal cruelty on China’s rapidly evolving animal protection debate. The changing status of dogs and certain wildlife issues ”“ fur, shark-finning ”“ have been most significant in contributing to the momentum for legislation. We gain an insight into the pace and direction of this debate from China’s vast digital media, which have played a crucial role in both publicizing abuse and galvanizing the increasingly organized domestic animal protection community. Although law remains at the draft stage and challenging obstacles remain, there are broad indications that the end may be in sight for this ”˜long march’.

Paul Littlefair, Head of External Affairs, RSPCA

 

Protecting All Creatures from Domestic Violence: Civil and Criminal Approaches, Challenges, and Solutions

Plenary Panel
Wood Hall building Room 8

This panel will address criminal and civil remedies to the harms of domestic violence, including how proponents of each can more effectively work together to provide an umbrella approach to protect human and animal victims. Panelists will discuss current ways that prosecutors and domestic violence advocates work together, future potential for collaboration, and challenges facing each approach.

Dr. Maya Gupta, Executive Director, Ahimsa House
Scott Heiser, Director, Criminal Justice Program, Animal Legal Defense Fund

 

12:45 – 2:00 p.m. PT

Lunch & Keynote Address

Legal Research Center building

 

1:15 – 1:45 p.m. PT

Keynote Address: Animal Welfare in a Livable Community

Legal Research Center building

Introduction by Kathy Hessler, director and clinical professor of law, Lewis & Clark Law School

Congressman Earl Blumenauer, 3rd District of Oregon

 

2:00 – 3:30 p.m. PT

Change the World for Animals

Plenary Panel
Wood Hall building Room 7

Join the chicks of Our Hen House, Jasmin Singer and Mariann Sullivan, for this interactive workshop — back by popular demand from last year’s conference — covering the many ways we can each effectively change the world for animals. Our Hen House, named by VegNews Magazine as the Indie Media Powerhouse, is a multimedia hub of opportunities to mainstream the movement to end animal exploitation. Jasmin and Mariann, the founders — and the hosts of the popular Our Hen House podcast — will brainstorm ideas on how each person can make their own unique contribution to building a new world free of animal exploitation, and how each of us can best use our own particular skills, talents and experience in this quest. In this energetic workshop with animal law professor Mariann, and writer Jasmin, ideas for turning thought into action, and action into real change, will be exchanged and discussed. Be prepared to ask questions, brainstorm ideas, and, ultimately, to leave feeling invigorated to change the world for animals.

Jasmin Singer, Co-founder and Executive Director, Our Hen House
Mariann Sullivan, Lecturer in Law, Columbia Law School

 

What's New in Litigation & Legislation?

Wood Hall building Room 8

This panel will discuss the latest developments in both state and federal legislation and will also highlight recent animal law litigation of particular interest to the movement.

Matthew Liebman, Associate Professor & Chair of the Justice for Animals Program, University of San Francisco School of Law
Nancy Perry, Senior Vice President of Government Relations, The American Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals (ASPCA)

 

3:45 – 5:15 p.m. PT

Animal Rights Isolationism v. Pragmatic Politics

Wood Hall building Room 7

Should animal rights activists compromise deeply held positions to achieve more limited goals in cooperation with the very industries they seek to change? Is the movement being co-opted by forces seeking to neutralize its effectiveness or is compromise the only way to bring about change?

Pamela Frasch, Founder, Center for Animal Law Studies, Lewis & Clark Law School
Joyce Tischler, Professor of Practice, Center for Animal Law Studies, Lewis & Clark Law School

 

Protecting Wildlife: Lessons Learned from the Environment Law Movement

Wood Hall building Room 8

These nationally recognized experts will shed light on the current pressing issues surrounding the wildlife law movement, the overlapping concerns of the environmental and animal law movement, and will explain how both movements can learn from one another to advance their respective goals.

Ralph Henry, Deputy Director, Animal Protection Litigation, The Humane Society of the United States
Daniel Rohlf, Professor of Law and of Counsel, Earthrise Law Center, Lewis & Clark Law School

 

5:15 – 6:00 p.m. PT

Reception

Legal Research Center Building

 

6:00 – 9:00 p.m. PT

Banquet Dinner, Keynote Address & Book Signing

Legal Research Center Building

 

7:00 – 8:15 p.m. PT

Keynote Address: After Twenty Years: animal Activism and Histories We Cannot Possess

Legal Research Center Building
Introductions and welcome

Jaclyn Leeds, SALDF co-director; symposium editor, Animal Law Review; conference board member, Lewis & Clark Law School

Pamela Frasch, assistant dean, Animal Law Program; executive director, Center for Animal Law Studies at Lewis & Clark Law School

Robert Klonoff, dean and professor of law, Lewis & Clark Law School

Taylor Duty, SALDF outreach chair; conference board member; associate editor, Animal Law Review, Lewis & Clark Law School

*Book Signing of the 20th Anniversary Edition of The Sexual Politics of Meat to follow Keynote Presentation

Carol J. Adams, Author of, The Sexual Politics of Meat

 

Sunday

8:00 – 9:15 a.m. PT

Thriving on Vegan Nutrition

Wood Hall building Room 7

Renowned physician, Dr. Michael Greger, will discuss nutrition and how intensive animal agriculture wreaks havoc on animals, the environment and our health. Robert Cheeke, best-selling author and two-time natural bodybuilding champion, will talk about his transition to a vegan lifestyle and will explain how vegan nutrition enhances health and athletic performance.

Robert Cheeke, Author, Vega Ambassador and Professional Vegan Bodybuilder
Dr. Michael Greger, Director, Public Health and Animal Agriculture, The Humane Society of the United States

 

New Voice in Animal Law

Wood Hall building Room 8

This panel brings together newcomers to the animal law field who are doing exciting and important work. Alexis Fox oversees all of HSUS’ legislative and lobbying efforts in Massachusetts and is a 2009 graduate of Lewis and Clark Law School. Jessica Johnson is the grassroots advocacy manager at the ASPCA, where she works on increasing grassroots participation in animal protection initiatives, and is a 2011 graduate of Lewis & Clark Law School. Join these two “new voices” as they explain their paths to success from law school to their respective careers in animal law.

Alexis Fox, Massachusetts state director, The Humane Society of the United States
Jessica Johnson, Senior Grassroots Advocacy Manager, Government Relations, ASPCA

 

9:30 – 11:00 a.m. PT

Exploring the Viability of Sustainable Meat

Wood Hall building Room 7

As ethical questions arise about intensive farming practices, society and producers have been struggling with the definition and feasibility of “sustainable meat.” Hear a range of perspectives from industry representative Dennis Treacy, to local farm promoter Kendra Kimbirauskas, to Farm Sanctuary senior director and vegan Bruce Friedrich, as they attempt to answer pressing questions about the ethics and viability of meat for future generations.

Bruce Friedrich, Senior Director for Strategic Initiatives, Farm Sanctuary
Kendra Kimbirauskas, President, Friends of Family Farmers
Dennis Treacy, Executive Vice President and Chief Sustainability Officer, Smithfield Foods, Inc.

 

Protecting Marine Mammals through Popular Culture and Global Negotiation

Wood Hall building Room 7

From Whale Wars to international negotiations, this panel will discuss the variety of ways advocates can help marine mammals. Kim McCoy has held positions as the quartermaster and international executive director of the Sea Shepherd Conservation Society, has advocated for animals through her work with Shark Angels and is the new executive director of One World One Ocean Foundation. Chris Wold will offer an international perspective on this controversial aspect of wildlife law, sharing his expertise in international environmental law and marine law.

Kim McCoy, Executive Director, One World One Ocean Foundation
Chris Wold, Professor of Law and Director, International Environmental Law Project, Lewis & Clark Law School

 

11:15 a.m. – 12:45 p.m. PT

Learning from Difficult Cases: Tilikum v. Seaworld

Wood Hall building Room 7

Difficult strategic decisions need to be made when bringing creative lawsuits to benefit animals. This panel will address the legal foundations for the “Tilikum” case and explore the strategic decision-making involved in filing this case that asked for protection against and direct recognition of the harm suffered by the orcas at SeaWorld. This is juxtaposed with cases where courts are asked to address the harm suffered by humans who feel injured by harm to animals.

Kathy Hessler, Director, Animal Law Education Initiative, The George Washington University Law School
Jeff Kerr, General Counsel and Vice President of Corporate Affairs, PETA Foundation

 

Subsidizing Inequity

Wood Hall building Room 8

Law professor and food activist Pamela Vesilind joins clean water lawyer and activist Martha Noble to examine the impact that government subsidies have on food access and awareness throughout the United States. This panel will provide an overview of agricultural subsidization and dissect the legal and policy implications.

Pamela Vesilind, Assistant Professor of Law, Vermont Law School
Martha Noble, Vice President, Clean Water Network

 

12:45 – 1:45 p.m. PT

Lunch

Legal Resource Center Building

 

2:00 – 3:30 p.m. PT

Animal Enterprise Terrorism Act

Wood Hall building Room 7

The Animal Enterprise Terrorism Act (AETA) became a federal law on November 27, 2006, through procedures typically used to expedite the passage of non-controversial bills. It criminalizes any conduct or speech that is intended to damage or interfere with the operations of an animal enterprise. It covers acts that cause actual damage or that place a person in reasonable fear of injury, as well as acts that cause no harm or damage. For those individuals whose conduct may be lawful, they, nonetheless, may be liable for any unlawful acts by unknown actors. Odette Wilkens and Lauren Regan will discuss the effect this bill has had on the civil liberties of animal rights activists.

Lauren Regan, Founder and Executive Director, Civil Liberties Defense Center
Odette Wilkens, Executive Director, Equal Justice Alliance

 

Defending the Family: Protecting Human-Companion Animal Relationships

Wood Hall building Room 8

The Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA), breed bans, and landlord-tenant law all play a substantial role in determining whether a person is able to live with particular companion animals. Ledy VanKavage has a long history of advocating for companion animals and will discuss the impact that breed bans have on animal guardians and the recent victory the movement received in the “Saks” case.

Ledy VanKavage, Senior Legislative Attorney, Best Friends Animal Society

 

3:45 – 5:15 p.m. PT

Student Career Summit

Wood Hall building Room 7

Speakers from a variety of professional backgrounds will present ideas about how to build animal law into your career after law school. The format for this session will be “round-table,” with presenters sharing their personal experiences yet also allowing plenty of time for audience questions and comments. Bring your ideas!

Emily Davidsohn, Staff Attorney and Case Coordinator, Oregon Humane Society
Andrew Freeman, Assistant District Attorney, Washington County District Attorney’s Office
Mark Jordan, Attorney, Nonprofit Support Services
Tom Linney, Pro Bono Program Director, Animal Legal Defense Fund

 

Carol J. Adams

Author of
The Sexual Politics of Meat

Congressman Earl Blumenauer

3rd District of Oregon

Lewis Bollard

Law Student
Yale Law School

Robert Cheeke

Author, Vega Ambassador and Professional Vegan Bodybuilder

Emily Davidsohn

Staff Attorney and Case Coordinator
Oregon Humane Society

Taylor Duty

3L
Lewis & Clark Law School

Alexis Fox

Massachusetts state director
The Humane Society of the United States

Pamela Frasch

Founder
Center for Animal Law Studies, Lewis & Clark Law School

Andrew Freeman

Assistant District Attorney
Washington County District Attorney’s Office

Bruce Friedrich

Senior Director for Strategic Initiatives
Farm Sanctuary

Dr. Michael Greger

Director, Public Health and Animal Agriculture
The Humane Society of the United States

Dr. Maya Gupta

Executive Director
Ahimsa House

Scott Heiser

Director
Criminal Justice Program, Animal Legal Defense Fund

Ralph Henry

Deputy Director, Animal Protection Litigation
The Humane Society of the United States

Kathy Hessler

Director
Animal Law Education Initiative, The George Washington University Law School

Jessica Johnson

Senior Grassroots Advocacy Manager, Government Relations
ASPCA

Jeffrey Jones

Professor of Law
Lewis & Clark Law School

Mark Jordan

Attorney
Nonprofit Support Services

Jeff Kerr

General Counsel and Vice President of Corporate Affairs
PETA Foundation

Kendra Kimbirauskas

President
Friends of Family Farmers

Robert Klonoff

Dean and Professor of Law
Lewis & Clark Law School

Jaclyn Leeds

SALDF co-director; symposium editor
Animal Law Review
Conference Board Member
Lewis & Clark Law School

Kelly Levenda

Student Programs Attorney
Animal Legal Defense Fund

Matthew Liebman

Associate Professor & Chair of the Justice for Animals Program
University of San Francisco School of Law

Tom Linney

Pro Bono Program Director
Animal Legal Defense Fund

Paul Littlefair

Head of External Affairs
RSPCA

Kim McCoy

Executive Director
One World One Ocean Foundation

Russ Mead

The Shared Earth Foundation Visiting Professor
Center for Animal Law Studies, Lewis & Clark Law School

Martha Noble

Vice President
Clean Water Network

Nicole Pallotta

Senior Policy Program Manager
Animal Legal Defense Fund

Nancy Perry

Senior Vice President of Government Relations
The American Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals (ASPCA)

Will Potter

Journalist and Author
GreenIsTheNewRed.com

Lauren Regan

Founder and Executive Director
Civil Liberties Defense Center

Daniel Rohlf

Professor of Law and of Counsel
Earthrise Law Center, Lewis & Clark Law School

Paul Shapiro

Vice President
Farm Animal Protection, The Humane Society of the United States

Jasmin Singer

Co-founder and Executive Director
Our Hen House

Mariann Sullivan

Lecturer in Law
Columbia Law School
Host
The Animal Law Podcast

Joyce Tischler

Professor of Practice
Center for Animal Law Studies, Lewis & Clark Law School

Dennis Treacy

Executive Vice President and Chief Sustainability Officer
Smithfield Foods, Inc.

Ledy VanKavage

Senior Legislative Attorney
Best Friends Animal Society

Pamela Vesilind

Assistant Professor of Law
Vermont Law School
Fellow in the Center for Agriculture and Food Systems

Bruce Wagman

Partner
Schiff Hardin

Odette Wilkens

Executive Director
Equal Justice Alliance

Chris Wold

Professor of Law and Director, International Environmental Law Project
Lewis & Clark Law School

Mandatory Continuing Legal Education (MCLE, or CLE) credits will be available for both conference and live webinar participants who register for CLE. The Oregon State Bar accredited the conference for 11.25 general credits and 1.25 ethics credits for a total of 12.5 CLE credits. Sessions that were not approved for credits were: Thriving on Vegan Nutrition; New Voices in Animal Law; the Student Career Summit; and the Keynote Presentations.

Attendees registered for CLE credits for the conference or webinar received a certificate of attendance at the conference or after the webinar via email. Webinar participants saw a code on the projection screen during each CLE-accredited session. These codes could be noted by the webinar participants in case of a CLE audit.

Please direct any questions relating to CLE credits to events@aldf.org.